An opinion editorial by Australian Chamber CEO James Pearson
All eyes in the business community will be on Energy Minister Josh Frydenberg and his state and territory counterparts this Friday.
How much longer are they prepared to let the energy crisis hold household budgets to ransom and bludgeon Australian businesses?
The COAG Energy Council needs to decide: will they take action to lower energy costs or not?
And it really is up to them, because they are the ones at the steering wheel.
Years of uncertainty, a result of a mish-mash of ideologically driven policies by different governments in different parts of the country, have helped drive down generation capacity and drive up electricity costs.
Yet uncertainty isn’t the only, or even the main factor, driving prices higher.
The ACCC has highlighted the significant role network costs have played – and the network operators are largely regulated monopolies.
Similarly, both the Grattan Institute and Victorian Government have in highlighted the important role that retail costs have played.
The reality is that there are problems at all levels – generation capacity, networks and retail markets.
If governments across the country are sincere in wanting lower energy costs, and they should be if we don’t want to force business to shrink, close or relocate overseas, then all these issues need to be addressed as part of an integrated national energy policy.
Our members, who represent businesses of all sizes in every sector and in every state and territory, are telling me that we are running out of time.
The ACCC estimates that network costs themselves accounted around half of the increase in electricity prices in 2015-16.
State and territory governments bear a lot of the blame.
The reliability and safety standards that they require create higher compliance costs for network operators, who then pass these costs on.
Safety and reliability are very important, but several reviews have found that these standards have, in some cases, been needlessly high, and led to overinvestment and higher electricity prices for consumers.
The energy ministers need to think carefully as they flesh out the detail of the National Energy Guarantee (NEG).
They can’t allow reliability standards to be baked into the NEG that will push costs higher, within a framework where the network operators are guaranteed a rate of return on their assets.
That’s a risk we face, whether it’s further overinvestment in poles and wires or dispatchable generation capacity.
To avoid an energy sector Groundhog Day, COAG should introduce, alongside the NEG, policies that tackle other factors pushing energy costs higher.
COAG should explore ways to reduce the high level of market concentration in the wholesale and retail markets.
We need to reduce the high level of market concentration in the wholesale market.
The big three generators supply about 70% of retail customers across the NEM. The electricity market would benefit from more competition, something that might, in-turn, help deal with over-capitalisation in network infrastructure.
Asset write-downs should be on the table for the electricity market.
The problem of excessive network costs, in a heavily regulated market, could be solved in part this way.
The ACCC has called for a similar policy with the National Broadband Network (NBN).
If other policies don’t deliver significant short-term cost reductions, then this option could be exercised.
It’s high time that state and territory governments changed the Stop sign to Go on the gas resources they hold.
It makes no sense to lock up the landscape when increased gas supply could help drive costs to consumers down.
As well as welcoming business to explore and develop gas, with project specific environmental approvals, other restrictions that impede the development and supply of gas resources should be reviewed and where possible removed.
That includes giving serious thought about how best to encourage landowners to facilitate access for exploration and development to the resources owned by the community (the Crown) underneath their land.
The NEG could well be a very important part of the solution, but energy ministers meeting this week must look beyond the NEG, because the NEG by itself won’t be enough to reduce energy costs for business and households in the short-term.
We encourage Josh Frydenberg to work with his state and territory colleagues to deliver an outcome beyond the lowest common denominator this Friday.
We hope these ideas will help.
The Australian Chamber of Commerce and Industry welcomes the news that five States and Territories have signed on to the Federal Government’s apprenticeship-focused national partnership...
Stronger profits are driving jobs and wage growth in data released from the Australian Bureau of Statistics today. However the Australian Chamber of Commerce and...
Small business risks being pushed further out of the economy by the Fair Work Commission’s decision today to lift minimum and award wages by 3.5%...
A new system unveiled today to link supply chain information through blockchain technology will revolutionise international trade by removing complexity. PwC Australia, the Australian Chamber...
“The small improvement in Australia's competitiveness ranking – from 21st to 19th - is welcome,...
The latest claims by the ACTU that 40% of Australians are in insecure work are false and misleading, the Australian Chamber of Commerce and Industry...
The Labor Party’s recognition of the need to pay down debt and for a buffer...
The 2017 Student Experience Survey released today, provides much-needed insights into the experience of students in our higher education system and serves as a reminder...
“On behalf of Australian industry, the Australian Chamber welcomes the Australian Government’s response to China's draft cyber supervision laws," Australian Chamber CEO, James Pearson, said today. “We...
The Australian Chamber – Tourism welcomes measures in the Federal Budget 2018 that support tourism growth. Executive Chair, John Hart said “the Government has invested...
The Federal Budget 2018 is heading in the right direction but business would have liked more ambition for long-term budget repair and decreased reliance on...
Australia’s leading business voice, the Australian Chamber of Commerce and Industry, says that employers will look beyond the headlines on tax when assessing next week’s...
The leading voice of business in Australia, the Australian Chamber of Commerce and Industry, rejects the ACTU’s attempt to scapegoat temporary migrants, and stoke the...
The decision by the US Government to exempt Australia from its steel and aluminium tariffs is welcomed by the Australian Chamber of Commerce and Industry....
The Labor Party’s proposal to give the Fair Work Commission more powers would see unions applying for orders to compel employers to accept their demands if...
For the ACTU to claim today that it is standing up for the independence of the Fair Work Commission shows either ignorance or conceit. It’s...
Saturday, 28 April is World Day for Safety and Health at Work, and Workers’ Memorial Day. It is a day to promote safety and health in...
The Australian Chamber of Commerce and Industry welcomes recognition the Australian workplace relations system is too complex by the Australian Small Business and Family Enterprise...
Today’s report in The Australian newspaper that the Labor Opposition would abolish the Australian Building and Construction Commission (ABCC) and reinstate the failed Road Safety...
The Australian Chamber of Commerce and Industry welcomes the decision of the COAG Energy Council to progress development of the detailed design of the National...