An opinion editorial by Australian Chamber CEO James Pearson
All eyes in the business community will be on Energy Minister Josh Frydenberg and his state and territory counterparts this Friday.
How much longer are they prepared to let the energy crisis hold household budgets to ransom and bludgeon Australian businesses?
The COAG Energy Council needs to decide: will they take action to lower energy costs or not?
And it really is up to them, because they are the ones at the steering wheel.
Years of uncertainty, a result of a mish-mash of ideologically driven policies by different governments in different parts of the country, have helped drive down generation capacity and drive up electricity costs.
Yet uncertainty isn’t the only, or even the main factor, driving prices higher.
The ACCC has highlighted the significant role network costs have played – and the network operators are largely regulated monopolies.
Similarly, both the Grattan Institute and Victorian Government have in highlighted the important role that retail costs have played.
The reality is that there are problems at all levels – generation capacity, networks and retail markets.
If governments across the country are sincere in wanting lower energy costs, and they should be if we don’t want to force business to shrink, close or relocate overseas, then all these issues need to be addressed as part of an integrated national energy policy.
Our members, who represent businesses of all sizes in every sector and in every state and territory, are telling me that we are running out of time.
The ACCC estimates that network costs themselves accounted around half of the increase in electricity prices in 2015-16.
State and territory governments bear a lot of the blame.
The reliability and safety standards that they require create higher compliance costs for network operators, who then pass these costs on.
Safety and reliability are very important, but several reviews have found that these standards have, in some cases, been needlessly high, and led to overinvestment and higher electricity prices for consumers.
The energy ministers need to think carefully as they flesh out the detail of the National Energy Guarantee (NEG).
They can’t allow reliability standards to be baked into the NEG that will push costs higher, within a framework where the network operators are guaranteed a rate of return on their assets.
That’s a risk we face, whether it’s further overinvestment in poles and wires or dispatchable generation capacity.
To avoid an energy sector Groundhog Day, COAG should introduce, alongside the NEG, policies that tackle other factors pushing energy costs higher.
COAG should explore ways to reduce the high level of market concentration in the wholesale and retail markets.
We need to reduce the high level of market concentration in the wholesale market.
The big three generators supply about 70% of retail customers across the NEM. The electricity market would benefit from more competition, something that might, in-turn, help deal with over-capitalisation in network infrastructure.
Asset write-downs should be on the table for the electricity market.
The problem of excessive network costs, in a heavily regulated market, could be solved in part this way.
The ACCC has called for a similar policy with the National Broadband Network (NBN).
If other policies don’t deliver significant short-term cost reductions, then this option could be exercised.
It’s high time that state and territory governments changed the Stop sign to Go on the gas resources they hold.
It makes no sense to lock up the landscape when increased gas supply could help drive costs to consumers down.
As well as welcoming business to explore and develop gas, with project specific environmental approvals, other restrictions that impede the development and supply of gas resources should be reviewed and where possible removed.
That includes giving serious thought about how best to encourage landowners to facilitate access for exploration and development to the resources owned by the community (the Crown) underneath their land.
The NEG could well be a very important part of the solution, but energy ministers meeting this week must look beyond the NEG, because the NEG by itself won’t be enough to reduce energy costs for business and households in the short-term.
We encourage Josh Frydenberg to work with his state and territory colleagues to deliver an outcome beyond the lowest common denominator this Friday.
We hope these ideas will help.
The Australian Chamber is delighted to announce Bryan Clark, Director of ACCI Trade & International Affairs, has been appointed to the Government’s Deregulation Taskforce, announced...
Australia’s largest network of businesses, the Australian Chamber of Commerce and Industry, has welcomed the Federal Government’s plan to increase funding for the Export Market...
Australia’s official employer representative to the United Nations’ International Labour Organisation (ILO), the Australian Chamber of Commerce and Industry, welcomes a report overnight from the...
Australia’s largest voice for Small Business, the Australian Chamber of Commerce and Industry, today launched...
The Labor Party’s plan to introduce a living wage will hurt small businesses and the job prospects of workers it is supposed to help, the...
“High costs at home and the need to come up with new or improved products and services are major challenges facing Australian business as they...
Labor's small business policy released yesterday is welcome recognition of the importance of small business to jobs and the economy, Australia's largest voice for small business, the Australian...
Business welcomes the Federal Government’s plan to manage population growth in a more coordinated way, Australia’s largest network of businesses, the Australian Chamber of Commerce...
Australia’s largest network of businesses, the Australian Chamber of Commerce and Industry, has welcomed the announcement by Kelly O'Dwyer, Minister for Jobs and Industrial Relations, of...
The reduction in permanent migration announced by the Government today is not justified by the evidence, Australia’s largest network of businesses, the Australian Chamber of...
The outlook for Australian manufacturing is becoming increasingly uncertain, with the first quarter 2019 results of the Australian Chamber of Commerce and Industry - Westpac...
Calls for Parliament to set minimum wages based on 60% of median wages would breach Australia’s international treaty obligations, the Australian Chamber of Commerce and...
Australia’s peak body of tourism organisations, the Australian Chamber-Tourism welcomes reports today that the Government has announced a new campaign to attract more working holidaymakers...
Australian employers, employees and job-seekers need to be assured that the Fair Work umpire would remain truly independent in setting minimum wages if Labor wins...
Australia’s temporary skilled visa system is no longer effective in targeting genuine skills shortages faced by Australian businesses, Australia’s largest network of businesses, the Australian...
There is now more reason than ever for next month’s Federal Budget to contain economy-growing policies following the release of the latest National Accounts, Australia’s...
"The Opposition Leader’s reported call to move from a minimum wage to a so-called “living wage” – a proposal pushed by ACTU boss Sally McManus...
The Australian Council of Trade Union’s (ACTU) plan to remove power from employees and employers and hand it to union officials they have never met,...
The Australian Government announced a biosecurity levy in the 2018 budget due to be implemented this July that is significantly flawed. As Australian industry participants...
Australia’s largest network of businesses, the Australian Chamber of Commerce and Industry, will join Australian Trade Minister Simon Birmingham and Indonesian Trade Minister Enggartiasto Lukita...